A short take - Game 2 of the World Championship 2021
The second game of the FIDE World Championship Dubai 2021 was an incredibly exciting encounter. Everyone was on the edge of their seat and kept wondering whether we will see a decisive result in a Classical game at a World Championship for the first time since 2016. Well, the answer is clear now, we have to wait a bit longer. If yesterday was a sign of things to come then rest assured, the wait will not be a longer one. While both players have shown incredible preparation in the first two games, we also got to witness the humane side of them. Even the toughest gladiators fall on an unfortunate day, that day was not yesterday. Photo: Amruta Mokal
Whose woods these are I think I know.
His house is in the village though;
He will not see me stopping here
To watch his woods fill up with snow.
My little horse must think it queer
To stop without a farmhouse near
Between the woods and frozen lake
The darkest evening of the year.
He gives his harness bells a shake
To ask if there is some mistake.
The only other sound's the sweep
Of easy wind and downy flake.
The woods are lovely, dark and deep,
But I have promises to keep,
And miles to go before I sleep,
And miles to go before I sleep.
- Robert Frost
All these attempts at watching the game live, analysing the game subsequently and writing articles, doing podcasts are nothing but "giving the bells a shake and ask if there is some mistake" for, as Savielly Tartakover said, "Chess owes its existence to mistakes! " What is the move? We think we know, amidst the woods and frozen lake, but moves keep escaping the attention, positions keep looking bizarre, crazy and the players swim through current and muddy waters most of the time!
This is the pure art of Chess, my friend! Like in life, we never know where we are going, what we are doing, except for that inkling which is mere delusion! Acceptance is the key, be it chess or life and that doesn't preclude our trying, 'effort' (if you may wish to use this term!) over the board!
It was an intensely fought game. The above was a rare occasion where both players stayed on the board with deep focus! At times, the clock was running, and the playing arena looked... empty.
Carlsen - Nepomniachtchi, Game 2
1.d4 Nf6 2.c4 e6 3.Nf3 d5 4.g3 Be7 5.Bg2 0-0 6.0-0 dc4 7.Qc2 b5 8.Ne5 c6 9.a4 Nd5
Lot has been spoken about Catalan and the order of moves that happened in this game. You may watch the video of commentary on youtube. Vishy was phenomenal as usual with his positional insights, witty remarks and anecdotes! Though, to a quirky question by a twitter user - on whose commentary would Carlsen and Nepo prefer to listen if they are not the playing the World Championship Match (...huh!?), Carlsen's reply was point-blank "I am really sorry.... I don't even remotely care"
And so we are...!
10.Nc3 f6 11.Nf3 Qd7 12.e4 Nb4 13.Qe2 Nd3
Appears as if something serious happened so early, as we don't get to see opponent knight perched so deep into our territory every other day! Let me put it this way, this knight on d3 is a thorn in white's flesh taking away some important squares from white's rooks, and we actually don't know where to develop that bishop on c1 (the proverbial saying that the queen's bishop is already well-developed on c1 itself in many lines, does not hold good here as it really hinders coordination amongst the rooks to say the least.)
At best we can say, Black is very comfortable.
14.e5 Bb7 15.exf6 Bxf6 16.Ne4 Na6
The critical moment from White's angle.
Carlsen did mention in the post game conference that, the move 18...Nac5! escaped his attention, and it was an unpleasant surprise to see that knight there!
Perhaps, this was the moment for the Bishop to develop to e3 or even 17.Nxf6 comes to consideration. But the position is very comples and when a player of the calibre of Carlsen can feel confused, then...
17.Ne5 Bxe5 18.dxe5 and the white knight landing on d6 like his counterpart reaching d3, is definitely a sensible way to approach this position. Only in hindsight, we find it wasn't good and chess is never played with the knowledge of hindsight, nor we live and decide things every moment with the knowledge of hindsight!
17.Ne5 Bxe5 18.dxe5 Nac5 19.Nd6 Nb3 20.Rb1 Nbxc1 21.Rbxc1 Nxc1 22.Rxc1 Rab8 23.Rd1 Ba8 24.Be4
The move perhaps eluded Nepo when he chose to play 23...Ba8 and hence in a state of confusion, he pushed his pawn to 24...c3. Vishy in the commentary box was favouring the move 24...bxa4! when Black appears to be pressing hard for a big advantage.
Carlsen felt that his Bishop on e4 with the great knight on d6 and the prospects on the light squares around the king are sufficient to keep Black busy and not think about his material plus on the other side of the chessboard!
Let me digress a bit here
"What then is the meaning of the whole world? We do not know what the meaning of existence is. We say, as the result of studying all of the views that we have had before, we find that we do not know the meaning of existence; but in saying that we do not know the meaning of existence, we have probably found the open channel - if we will allow only that, as we progress, we leave open opportunities for alternatives, that we do not become enthusiastic for the fact, the knowledge, the absolute truth, but remain always uncertain. Muddling through - although a rather silly, stupid sounding thing - is the most scientific way of progressing. To decide upon the answer is not scientific. In order to make progress, one must leave the door to the unknown ajar - ajar only." - Richard Feynman (from The Pleasure of Finding Things Out)
The meaning of moves, ideas on the chessboard is no different from the above! Muddling through is the way in chess too! We grope through darkness for the most part, allowing channels to open for both the players. To decide on a particular move is not the path - thought that is what we seemingly do. But in effect it is the pieces that move around, and we only provide open channels for their maneuvers!
Give a damn to the engine suggestions here on what could Black have played instead of 24...c3
I am certainly not going to give alternatives or variations here, both are futile!
This Queen maneuver is exquisite! What Carlsen said about this and his subsequent moves is also equally beautiful - the mind of the master: "I didn't feel I had great chances per se... but did feel that my position was improving a bit and when I went for this 37.Qg4, my time was ticking a bit as I couldn't see a way to comfortably improve my position and that's why I decided to basically force a draw there. If it had been a must win game, I would have treated it differently!"
That is the essence of chess and chess mastery. The choices of moves have a bearing on the situation in a match or tournament and there is no objectively best move in any position other than the concrete one's like combination and endgames where there is a finish.
Rest of the game, I give without any comment.
24...c3 25.Qc2 g6 26.bxc3 bxa4 27.Qxa4 Rfd8 28.Ra1 c5 29.Qc4 Bxe4 30.Nxe4 Kh8 31.Nd6 Rb6 32.Qxc5 Rdb8 33.Kg2 a6 34.Kh3 Rc6 35.Qd4 Kg8 36.c4 Qc7 37.Qg4 Rd6 38.exd6 Qxd6 39.c5 Qxc5 40.Qxe6+ Kg7 41.Rxa6 Rf8 42.f4 Qf5 43.Qxf5 Rxf5 44.Ra7 Kg8 45.Kg4 Rb5 46.Re7 Ra5 47.Re5 Ra7 48.h4 Kg7 49.h5 Kh6 50.Kh4 Ra1 51.g4 Rh1 52.Kg3 gxh5 53.Re6 Kg7 54.g5 Rg1 55.Kf2 Ra1 56.Rh6 Ra4 57.Kf3 Ra3 58.Kf2 Ra4 draw
And one of the questions that came their way, about the time the players spend time on the board after the game, discussing the moves.
Carlsen replied: "Well, it is interesting to talk to someone who understands chess very well and unwinding"
Nepo's reply aptly summed up the game and the question: "Well, I am actually puzzled with the game today and now even more puzzled with your question....to be honest"
About the Author
Govindaseshan Srikanth is a native of Chennai, with Tamil as his mother tongue and English as his favourite language of expression. He works with strong grandmasters like Sundararajan Kidambi, Vishnu Prasanna and helps them uncover their full chess potential. A keen reader of varied subjects such as philosophy, science, literature, neurology and Hindu spiritualism, Srikanth – Sri to his friends – is a connoisseur of Karnataka Samgita or Indian Carnatic music, one of the richest and most ancient classic music forms in the world. He writes his own chess blog and the above article has been taken from there with his kind permission.
The article was edited by Shahid Ahmed